One of the major complaints that a competing salesman had
against Professor Harold Hill, in the musical, "The Music Man,"
was, "He don't know the territory!"
Those attempting to sell anything from Coca Cola to computers
realize that it is necessary to know the territory. In other
words, market research is essential, in order to assess the
preferences of a given population. Without investigation, a
salesperson may try to sell freezers to Eskimos or left-hand-drive
American cars to right-hand-drive Japan.
"I would say that the greatest growth challenge facing the
church today is that (it) has not yet learned how to take a city.
Today the churches of Christ are numerically strong only in those
cities in which they grew up with the town. . . But we are yet to
go into a large, burgeoning city, plant a virgin work and
experience long term wholesale growth. Compounding that problem is
that we have not found a way to maintain momentum in a congregation
when the neighborhood changes its ethnic mix" (Michael Armour,
private correspondence, 1982).
And in January 1992, when a discussion was going on about the
difficulties encountered in penetrating the heart of large cities,
a prominent minister suggested that "perhaps the Lord didn't intend
for us to reach into these cities. Perhaps we should concentrate
instead on suburban areas and new housing developments."
In most cases, if we aim at establishing churches in the
world's great urban centers, we fail to take into consideration
that cities are not all the same or that a pre-planned strategy may
not succeed well in them. The Discipling Movement, based in
Boston, fails in this respect. To its leaders, all cities are
essentially the same. Therefore, they believe that the identical
method may be applied in all cases.
This is incorrect thinking. Although every city in the world
has much in common, such as poverty, crime, problems of keeping up
with city services, education, and the like, all cities are
different. This difference stems from the geographical setting,
ecology, history, industry, economy, political structure, people
groups, cultures, religious patterns, growth rate and other factors
at work in a particular city.
Our business as missiologists is to prepare evangelists today
to fulfill the same orders that Jonah received from God: "Go to
Nineveh (or Nanjing or New Delhi or Nantes), that great city." Our
business is to go where people are. Nowhere is there a greater
need for preaching a focused message of salvation than in the
world's great cities, where millions pass by on their way to a
hopeless destiny.
In order to focus our evangelism into the heart of urban
worldviews worldwide, we must first understand the city. We must
identify with it and communicate with it on its level and to its situation.
The first major stage is anthropological research of the city.
Anthropology is the study of man. Urban anthropology is the study
of man in the city. It stresses:
Urban anthropology looks at the ecology of cities. What makes
a city what it is geographically and physically? What is its
shape? Why has it formed in this way? How dense is its
population? What are projections for future growth?
Cities are shaped in part by ecological factors. They are
also shaped by human decisions. For instance, how is a particular
city structured? What kind of government is in place and how does
it shape the city? How much urban planning and renewal are going
on? Are there zones for different functions? The wise church
worker will pay close attention to the development of cities, for
evangelistic planning must fit into patterns of human growth and
mentality.
This method is valid in that it gives a broad perspective of
the city that anthropological methods cannot formally achieve.
Both are certainly necessary in urban research. Cities are too
large and complex to depend entirely on one research approach over
the other.
Sociology relies heavily on surveys. These include population
by age categories, life expectancy figures, professions, percentage
of population in different income levels, types of housing,
religious affiliations, educational levels, business and industry,
crime figures, health and welfare information and other such
figures.
For religious purposes, such matters as directions and rate of
growth of the city, immigration and changes of residence, literacy,
mental and spiritual health, ethnic mix and distribution, churches
and their growth and outreach, patterns of public transportation,
and feasibility studies for planting new churches in the city are
valid survey topics.
The first of these is to see the city through "church growth
eyes" (Wagner 1981). Without vision and planning, we may spend
many years in a city and never build a growth-oriented work.
The second requirement is to research and seek out receptive
units of an urban society. Factors such as migration, famine, war,
death, divorce or other traumatic events can facilitate receptivity
of groups and individuals.
A third consideration is that of expanding the base of
seekers. Once receptive elements are located, effective methods
for bringing them to a knowledge of Christ and to obedience must be
utilized.
Finally, it is important to present a sound Biblical message,
but his message must be contextualized; that is, clothed in the
garments of the particular group in question. Again, research will
help us determine how to find cultural bridges to that group.
Urban residents can be classified in many different ways. In
this study we will look briefly at webs, networks and associations.
Among all of the sub-units within the social complexity of a
city, two of the most important for the investigator of urban life
are family webs and networks of acquaintances. Both of these are
important channels of communication and mutual support in an
otherwise cold and inhuman atmosphere. That these channels
function has often been proved. News of a death or of some other
personal joy or calamity is transmitted rapidly throughout a city,
even in cases where there may be few telephones and automobiles to
aid in the communication process.
Family webs, even tough fractured in part by migration and the
pressures of urban life, are a basic structural element in cities,
especially those in which the extended family still has an
important role in society. This extended family may total several
hundred people, including godparents and their families, patrons
(those connected by ties of friendship, employment or mutual
interests) and any persons employed by the family or being reared
by it.
The urban researcher is duty-bound to explore family webs and
begin to penetrate them, in order to bring entire family units to
Christ, rather than scattered individuals. In exploring and
influencing extended families, however, it is important to make
first contact, if possible, with those recognized by the family as
its most influential members and spokespersons. If contact is
pursued with the youngest family members, or with family mavericks,
these richly-connected webs will remain largely closed to
investigation and evangelization.
Networks are another vital element in urban research.
According to Barnes, a pioneer researcher of networks,
There is a great diversity in networks and the ways in which
people use them in interacting with one another. Basic networks
are personal (anchored on a specific individual) or social
(involving a group). Individuals in a city are "the core of a
network of relationships which include various groupings, both
homogeneous and heterogeneous" (McConnell 1986:2-3). Davenport and
Davenport maintain that networks are based upon "kinship,
friendship, employment, recreation, politics, ethnicity, education,
religion or other common interests" (1982:106).
For the urban church worker, networks offer a rich opportunity
to study how relations develop and are maintained at different
levels of society. One informant may lead the researcher to many
other potential contacts, at different levels of society.
Incidentally, an individual in an urban setting actually has multi-
tiered network contacts. He or she may know people from top
government and business levels, down to those holding menial
positions in the city. Once such networking is understood, the
urban evangelist can penetrate it and use those with multiple-
network connections as bridges to reach even more networks.
In a sense cities are composed of thousands of "villages" of
associations, webs and networks, each a more or less homogeneous
unit within the larger units of the metropolitan area itself. If
the city appears too big a monster to bite into, it can be broken
down into smaller bite-sized pieces, represented by these
groupings.
One such grouping is associations. Hiebert says that
associations not only fulfill a primary function (for which they
ostensibly were formed), but other functions as well.
Associations are important to the religious researcher,
because they are special-interest sub-units in a city. These units
can become important connecting links or bridges to entire people
groups within the city.
Urban structures and groupings are natural. The wise urban
missiologist knows them well and uses them for the glory of Christ
and the natural expansion of his kingdom. Cities are too large and
complex, and workers are too few, to waste years in unproductive
efforts, which has often been the case historically.
Going to modern-day Ninevehs means much more than 40 days of
preaching, as in God's mandate to Jonah. It means years of
research and intimacy with the city and its ways, in order to
penetrate it along its existing human maps and leave it with
powerful, rather than pitiful, churches. Jeremiah urged Jewish
exiles in Babylon to seek the good of the city in which they found
themselves (Jer. 29:7). The greatest possible good that modern
megalopoli need is to be introduced to the Prince of Peace. Can we
do less than to carefully research the city, in order to find how
best to make this introduction meaningful and lasting in the urban
context?
Barnes, John A.
1954 "Class Committees in a Norwegian Island Parish." Human
Relations 7," February 1954.
Davenport, Judith and Joseph III
1982 "Utilizing the Social Network in Rural Communities,"
"Social Casework 63," February 1982.
Greenway, Roger S. and Monsma, Timothy
1989 Cities: Missions' New Frontier. Grand Rapids, Mich.:
Baker Book House.
Hiebert, Paul G.
1976 Cultural Anthropology. Philadelphia: J. B. Lippencott.
1982 Urban Anthropology and Church Planting. Pasadena, Calif:
Fuller Theological Seminary.
Lightbody, C. Stuart
1986 "New Strategies for a New Era." "Urban Mission," January
issue.
McConnell, C. Douglas
1985 Urban Ministries Training: Evaluating for Effectiveness.
Altadena, Calif.: Barnabas Resources.
Wagner, C. Peter
1981 Strategies for Church Growth. Pasadena, Calif.: Fuller
Theological Seminary.
n.a.
1991 Singapore: The Next Lap. Singapore: Government Printing
Office.
On The Urban Scene, We Must Know The Territory
by
Glover Shipp
CHRISTIAN CHRONICLE
Oklahoma City, Oklahoma
Negative Attitude Toward the City
What does this have to do with urban research? Everything!
Historically, many religious groups, and churches of Christ in
particular, have avoided the city, considering it hopelessly evil
and difficult to penetrate, and therefore, beyond the pale of our
spiritual responsibility. Hear what some have observed on this
attitude toward urban centers:
"There has been a tendency in our mission work to focus
attention on rural areas and pass by the great cities.
With few exceptions, missionaries have been concentrated
outside the urban centers, a policy which now is being
changed" (Lightbody, in Urban Mission, January 1986:30).
Inadequate Planning
This is our lingering attitude toward cities in our own
nation. How do we fare with the great megalopoli in foreign
countries? Perhaps a little better, for some of us see the need
for planting the church in them. However, in strategy sessions for
reaching the cities of Russia or Romania, Bulgaria or Brazil, China
or Chile, preliminary research of these centers is seldom
considered. The Continent of Great Cities ministry targets all of
the capitals of South America, which is truly visionary. Yet,
little thought is given to in-depth research of these cities,
before mapping strategies for them. On the contrary, strategies
are developed even before teams arrive on the field.
Each City Researched
Therefore, each city must be researched, evaluated and
strategized, because it embodies a unique personality and set of
challenges. As urban centers reach 10, 15, 20, 25 or more millions
of inhabitants, the challenges they pose to government and to the
church become more and more formidable. Actually, no one knows how
to manage a city of 25 to 50 million people. Such a challenge has
never been faced before.
Steps Toward Successful Urban Work
This calls for several steps, which must be relentlessly
instilled in future urban workers:
Anthropological Research
Someone has said that the worst one to ask about water is a
fish, because it is so accustomed to its environment that it takes
water for granted. Sometimes, like fish, we view a city, or even
live in it, without really seeing it. How then do we go about
taking a fresh, accurate look at Megalopolis?
Sociological Research
Urban research must also take into account sociological
methods, Sociological research stresses the larger groupings in a
city, their social behaviorism, the use of statistics and lab
settings, as well as real life, in analysis of the urban setting
and detached observation (Hiebert 1981:1). In other words,
sociological research looks at the forest more than at the trees,
deducing from this macro approach certain conclusions.
Church Growth Research
Church growth methodology can also be applied in doing urban
research for religious purposes. Effective evangelism and church
growth do not come automatically. There are certain research and
methodological requirements necessary, in order to encourage growth
of the Lord's kingdom in major cities.
Human Systems in the City
Cities are not merely physical structures, but also human
systems. The government of progressive Singapore, a blue-ribbon
example of urban development, stresses its most important product:
people, a rich and complex mosaic of people (from the government-
published book, Singapore:The Next Lap,1991).
"A network is a set of points some of which are joined by
lines. The points are people, or sometimes groups, and
the lines indicate which people interact with each other"
(1954:43).
They
". . . reinforce an individual's sense of personal identity,
of
validating his status in the community, and of exercising
social
control" (1976:245).
Researching Urban Worldviews
Urban research should also include individual and collective
worldview as it is modified by life in a large city. Worldviews in
cities are pluralistic, with the individual modifying certain
aspects of his or her assumptions, values, allegiances, culture and
habits, as association is made with diverse worldviews. In order
to convert others in an urban pluralistic society, it is necessary
to understand and help modify in a Christian manner the basic
assumptions and values of the individual. Understanding of
worldview and worldview change comes through observation,
participation and research (Shipp 1986:119-133).
Urban Societal Groupings
We need, desperately, to understand the various societal
groupings and classes in large cities. Each has worldview and
cultural habits of its own. We need to learn how to analyze these
levels, such as urban poor, and better determine how to penetrate
them successfully.
Conclusion
There are many other aspects of urban research that could be
explored, but suffice it to say, in closing, that the serious urban
church worker must know the territory. With a basic understanding
of how his or her city is organized and how its webs, networks,
associations and worldviews function, the worker can realize far
greater results than can be achieved without such research.
Bibliography
Armour, Michael
1982 Personal correspondence with the speaker.
Mirrored by permission of ACU Missions Personnel
Direct questions and comments to Ed Mathews,
![]()
Page maintained by